The best thing about the meeting between U.S.
President George W. Bush and Mexican president
Vicente Fox (with Canada's Prime Minister
Stephen Harper as witness) was that it was
planned for Cancun, a place that, after the
destruction wrought by Hurricane Wilma last
fall, literally needs all the help it can get
to regain its tourism. The worst thing about
the meeting was that it wasn't expected to
achieve much. It was like two neighbors who
bump into each other in a bar and, before they
part, say, "Let's have one for the road."
In fact, this was to be the last meeting
between both leaders before the presidential
election in Mexico, on July 2. After that date,
Fox will become a lame duck. Meanwhile, Bush
will still be fighting his war in Iraq, without
realizing that the part of the hemisphere to
the south of the U.S. border is turning left
and becoming increasingly more anti-American.
The Cancun meeting changes nothing in Mexico-U.S.
relations. The two presidents merely met to say
bye bye.
The relationship between Bush and Fox can only
be measured by results, not good intentions.
Bush and Fox, like a bored married couple,
started out supposedly as good friends and
ended up neglecting one another. There was no
real love. They made many promises at the
beginning and in the end neither came through.
The central theme of the relationship between
Fox and Bush was always immigration. Its
success or failure would be measured by whether
the United States and Mexico could negotiate an
immigration treaty, legalizing the presence of
undocumented immigrants and establishing a safe
and effective mechanism for new arrivals. The
two countries couldn't manage to do that.
Such an agreement wasn't even negotiated. Where
are the negotiators? When and where did they
meet? Where are the drafts for the agreement?
No matter what the U.S. Senate does in the
coming days, in five years Bush and Fox failed
to solve the problem that most worried them.
It is true that the terrorist attacks of Sept.
11, 2001, changed the U.S. agenda. Bush's two
eyes were focused on Osama and Saddam and he
didn't have a
third eye to see Vicente. But Mexico, too,
failed in convincing the United States that the
immigration issue goes hand in hand with its
war on terrorism.
Fox also failed to understand early on that in
the United States laws are changed in Congress,
which means visiting each and every legislator,
and spending tons of money for the best
lobbyists and public relations firms for
the job. But Fox's voice was seldom heard in
the United States.
In the last five years, every time there was
criticism of Mexican immigrants on television
or in English-language newspapers, there was no
counterpoint. There was no response from a
Mexican government spokesman.
Where are all those Mexicans who studied abroad
and who work for the government? Why aren't
they allowed to speak?
Mexico needs a whole army of spokesmen in the
United States. But it doesn't exist. Because of
that, the idea of erecting a wall between
Mexico and the United States has progressed
further than the idea of building a
bridge for immigrants to cross.
The first time George and Vicente met as
presidents was at Fox's ranch in San Cristobal,
Guanajuato. On Friday, Feb. 16, 2001, the two
had lunch on the patio, and afterward I saw
them relaxed, smoking cigars.
I was with a TV-crew in the sitting room at the
ranch, looking out the window, and I was
impressed by how well they seemed to get along.
They joked, they patted each other on the back.
Both were wearing boots. Neither was wearing a
tie. Both wanted to help Mexican immigrants in
the United States.
Both seemed to understand the problem. That
image, undoubtedly, represented the
undocumented immigrants' best hope.
But I should've noticed the clouds in the sky.
Before lunch, Bush had ordered an air raid on
Iraq. That was 25 months before the start of
the war in Iraq. It was Bush's bombs, not his
laughter with Fox, that said so much.
I don't believe Fox understood it at the time.
We were all misled. While Bush was saying Latin
America would be his priority, the bombs were
already exploding in Iraq. Now I realize that
that afternoon Bush's mind was far away,
thousands of miles from Fox's ranch in
Guanajuato.
In an interview, that same day, Bush told me
that if he ever caught Saddam Hussein building
weapons of mass destruction and threatening
security in the region, he would take action.
It was the prelude to the war and none
of us realized it. Not even Fox.
So, everything seems to indicate that the
relationship between Bush and Fox was not as
good and transparent as we thought at first. In
fact, it began with ambiguities and ended
without the prize. That better explains the
failure of both Mexico and the United States to
resolve the immigration issue.
Yes, it was the last one for the road. One can
only hope that those who follow will promise
less and do more.