WASHINGTON,
D.C. Nothing is more important for
America's future than immigration. The economy
will see ups and downs. Terrorism, at some
point, will stop threatening us. But immigrants
will forever leave their imprint on the United
States. And that is a good thing.
After debating (on television and in person)
with CNN's Lou Dobbs at least five times, I am
sure that nobody will be satisfied with
Congress's decision on immigration law reform,
however it turns out. But any reform must
include legalization of the 12 million
undocumented immigrants already here, as well
as provide work visas for those coming behind
them. It is fundamental for the future of the
United States.
Let us be clear.
When Dobbs and others call undocumented
immigrants "illegals," many people imagine
criminals and terrorists. And that perception
is wrong.
Here we are
speaking about people _ women, grandparents,
children, peasants, workers _ who had
absolutely nothing to do with the Sept. 11,
2001, terror acts. And while it is true they
broke the law by crossing the border or by
overstaying their visas, it is also true that
thousands of companies hire them and millions
of Americans profit from their work. We are all
accomplices.
It is almost impossible to spend a day without
benefiting from the work of undocumented
immigrants: we eat what they harvest, live in
the houses they build; they take care of our
children, pay their taxes, create jobs, do the
jobs Americans don't want, keep inflation under
control and pay retirement benefits _ Social
Security _ for a rapidly aging population.
Another mistaken
perception is that undocumented migrants take
out more than they put in to the economy.
False. In 1995, the National Academy of
Sciences concluded that all immigrants, legal
or not, contribute $10 billion a year to the
American economy. What is true is that the
federal government does not fairly allocate
immigrant income tax revenue to the cities,
counties
and states most affected by health and
education expenses for the immigrants.
That is not the
fault of the undocumented workers; the budget
can adjust that.
It is
unbelievable that the most diverse nation on
the planet subjects millions of human beings to
darkness and fear. Undocumented workers are
invisible to most Americans. They do not exist
on any official registry. But,
because of their economic and cultural
contributions, they deserve to stay.
And, no, it is
not an amnesty that the U.S. Senate is
discussing in the McCain-Kennedy proposal. If
this bill is passed in full by Congress and
signed into law by President George W. Bush, it
would send the undocumented immigrants to the
back of the queue and then it would take them,
on average, 11 years to become American
citizens (after paying a fine, learning English
and proving they have no unpaid taxes and are
not criminals).
The legalization
would solve part of the problem _ that of the
undocumented who are already here _ because the
alternative is unthinkable.
Deporting most of
the undocumented immigrants could cost up to
$240 billion.
I cannot even
begin to imagine TV videos of federal agents _
in Los Angeles, Chicago and Houston _ rounding
up families with infants and dragging them from
their homes and off to jails or detention
centers before being
deported. America's image around the world,
would end up damaged beyond repair and the
possibility of human rights violations is huge.
The other part of
the immigration problem involves the people
that continue to arrive. Every second, an
immigrant crosses illegally from Mexico into
the United States. Half a million enter every
year. And this will continue as long as workers
in the United States earn salaries 15 to 20
times
greater than what workers are paid for the same
job in Mexico.
Parity in the
salaries isn't likely to be achieved in less
than two decades. A massive foreign investment
program is needed in Mexico and Central America
to speed up this process. But that does not
exist. So, the only solution in the short term
is that it should be easier for an immigrant to
get a visa or work permit than sneaking in
illegally through deserts, rivers and
mountains.
I understand the
people who want to build more walls in front of
Mexico and to deploy the Army or 20,000 more
federal agents to the border. But let me tell
you something: it won't work. Hunger is
stronger than fear. A man or a woman suffering
hunger will do the impossible to cross the
border. He or she has nothing to lose because
they have already lost everything.
When Bush came to
office in 2001, 336 immigrants died on the
border. Last year, with the border reinforced,
that number grew to 460 deaths of undocumented
migrants. An immigration reform that
strengthens border security _ a legitimate U.S.
right _ but which does not offer legal entry to
the hundreds of thousands of undocumented
people arriving every year, will have a fatal
and immediate effect: more deaths on the
border.
Finally, the GOP
could pay a huge political price if Hispanic
voters blame the party for a law that does not
treat immigrants fairly. Hispanics not only
defined the presidential election in 2000, but
are already the biggest minority in the
country: according to my calculations based on
U.S. Census Office data, Latinos will be the
majority in the United States by 2125. Latino
voters will know soon who their real friends
are.
The identity and
strength of the United States is based upon its
diversity and its openness to new immigration.
That was made clear with the great protest in
Los Angeles _ in which more than half a million
people took part _ and the constant protests
across the nation by young high school Latinos
who also refuse to keep quiet in the face of
pending criminalization of immigrants.
It is now the
Senate's turn to do its job to protect the
multiethnic and multicultural future of the
United States. It is not giving away an amnesty
_ it is doing the right thing.